Why Measure Market Behavior Before Developing a Strategy?
The difference between researching market behavior and attempting to profit from it.
Why would anyone develop a trading strategy around market behavior they haven't first objectively defined and measured?
That question gets to the foundation of the Intra-Day Momentum Method™ (IDMM).
IDMM was developed to answer a relatively straightforward question:
What has the market, or an individual stock, actually done?
Not what it might do tomorrow. Not where someone thinks it should go. And not whether a particular indicator generates a profitable trading signal.
What has actually happened?
This may seem like an obvious question, but it represents an important difference between measuring market behavior and developing strategies intended to exploit that behavior.
The Scientific Argument
You cannot reliably evaluate the significance of a market behavior until you have objectively defined what you're measuring.
And you cannot determine whether that behavior offers an exploitable advantage until you have measured its outcomes.
The research process follows a logical sequence:
Define → Observe → Measure → Compare → Validate → Evaluate Applications
Consider a breakout strategy.
A trader observes that stocks sometimes continue higher after breaking above a particular price level.
But before developing a trading strategy around that observation, shouldn't we first ask:
What mathematically defines the breakout?
How frequently does that event occur?
What happens to price after the event?
How does that behavior compare with an appropriate baseline?
Does the observed relationship persist across different stocks and historical periods?
Is the relationship statistically reliable, or could it be explained by chance?
Without those answers, a trader may be optimizing a strategy around an assumption that has never been independently validated.
A profitable historical backtest does not necessarily establish that the underlying entry pattern provides the advantage. Profitability may also depend on exits, position sizing, risk management, or other components of the strategy.
These are separate questions that deserve separate investigation.
Measurement Is Not the Same as Strategy Development
There are three important considerations.
1. Measurement must precede meaningful interpretation.
An event needs an objective definition before its occurrences can be consistently identified and its outcomes measured.
A visual chart pattern may appear meaningful, but visual recognition alone does not establish a reproducible measurement.
The definition should specify the conditions that constitute an occurrence, allowing the event to be identified consistently across the data being examined.
2. Observation should be separated from optimization.
When researchers repeatedly modify definitions and parameters to improve historical performance, they risk introducing selection bias and overfitting.
Defining an event independently of a desired trading result helps reduce that risk.
The objective is first to establish what happened, rather than adjust the definition until a favorable result appears.
This does not eliminate the need for independent validation, but it provides a more disciplined starting point.
3. A measurable relationship is not necessarily a profitable opportunity.
An event may demonstrate a consistent historical relationship with subsequent price behavior without providing sufficient economic advantage after transaction costs, execution constraints, and risk.
For example, an event might be followed by a particular closing-price relationship in a substantial majority of observed sessions.
That observation may be statistically interesting.
But it does not automatically establish that a trader could have captured the outcome profitably.
Research findings and trading profitability are two different things.
Where IDMM Fits
IDMM does not begin with the assumption that its mathematically defined price levels will produce profitable trades.
It begins with a different proposition:
Markets generate observable price events. Those events can be mathematically defined, consistently identified, and statistically evaluated to establish what has historically occurred.
For example, IDMM uses the session opening price as an anchor and calculates mathematically defined price levels relative to that opening price.
The research can then identify when an individual security reaches those levels and examine what happens afterward.
Questions include:
How frequently does the security reach a defined price level?
How much time passes before the event occurs?
What happens to price after the level is reached?
Does price subsequently return to the opening price?
Where does the security close relative to its opening price?
How do these observations compare across different securities and historical periods?
These questions can be investigated using historical market data without introducing a trading strategy.
The purpose is to document observable market behavior.
The methodology can also support additional research into the relationships between different mathematically defined events, including reversals, fast moves, and the location of the opening price relative to previous trading ranges.
The objective remains the same: identify the event, measure its occurrence, and document the subsequent behavior.
Research in Practice
An example of this approach is the IDMM research covering 67 exchange-traded funds (ETFs).
The report examines mathematically defined price-level occurrences and their associated historical outcomes across multiple securities during a specified observation period.
Rather than presenting trading recommendations, the analysis documents the frequency and characteristics of the observed events.
This is the practical application of the measurement-first approach.
Why Negative Results Matter
There is another important consideration.
A negative research finding is still a finding.
If a mathematically defined event demonstrates no meaningful relationship with subsequent price behavior, the research has answered a legitimate question.
A strategy-development process focused exclusively on profitability may discard that result as a failed trading system.
A research methodology preserves the observation because understanding what does not demonstrate a useful relationship can be just as important as identifying what does.
This also creates an opportunity to compare different conditions and determine whether an observed relationship changes across securities, market environments, or historical periods.
Not every observation needs to produce a trading opportunity to have research value.
Two Different Questions
A trading strategy asks:
Can this market behavior be used to generate profitable trades?
IDMM begins by asking:
What is the market actually doing, how frequently does it occur, and what happens afterward?
Both are legitimate questions, but they are not interchangeable.
A trading strategy can certainly be developed and tested scientifically. The point is not that strategy development is inherently unscientific.
The point is that market behavior can be investigated independently of any proposed trading application.
An observed historical relationship may eventually provide a reason to investigate a trading strategy.
Or it may not.
Either outcome contributes to understanding the behavior being measured.
The Bottom Line
Scientific research should establish what is observable, measurable, and reproducible before attempting to determine what is predictable or profitable.
That is the purpose of IDMM.
It is not a trading bot, a collection of trading signals, or a claim that the market can be predicted.
It is a methodology for mathematically defining market events and documenting what markets and individual securities have historically done.
Whether those observations can subsequently be used to develop profitable trading strategies is another question entirely.
And that is precisely why the research matters.
About the Intra-Day Momentum Method™
The Intra-Day Momentum Method™ was developed by Todd Hudson as a mathematical framework for identifying and measuring intraday market behavior.
The methodology is described in the book Intra-Day Momentum Method – A Scientific Approach to Trading.
The Intra-Day Momentum Method - A Scientific Approach to Trading
The IDMM methodology is the subject of U.S. Patent Application No. 18/775,412, which received a Notice of Allowance from the United States Patent and Trademark Office on August 12, 2026. The issue fee has been paid, and patent issuance is pending, subject to confirmation of the application's current status.
A Notice of Allowance indicates that the USPTO has determined the identified claims are allowable. It does not constitute independent scientific validation of the methodology, its statistical findings, or its potential profitability.
Patent examination and empirical research address different questions.
The patent status concerns the intellectual property associated with the methodology. The research concerns the measurement and evaluation of observed market behavior.
Todd Hudson Creator, Intra-Day Momentum Method™ Author, Intra-Day Momentum Method – A Scientific Approach to Trading
0 comments
Log in to view comments
Sign in